Gorgon's head on a
silver
coin of Naples
permission to use
image granted
|
CLA 300:
Medicine, Miracle,
& Magic
Spring 2009
|
The god Apollo on a
gold coin
of Syracuse
image courtesy of Edgar
L. Owen, #3803
|
Instructor: Dr. Victor A. Leuci
Link: Web
resources for Greek Civilization
Texts:
- Print:
- Meridith B. McGuire,
Ritual Healing
in Suburban America
- Electronic or on
reserve:
- National Center for
Complementary and Alternative Medicine's web site
- American Medical
Association's web site (click here)
- Philostratus, The
Life of Apollonius of Tyana
- selections from Aelius Aristides, The
Sacred
Tales
- selections from
Greco-Roman medical & pharmocological works, e.g. The Hippocratic
Corpus, Galen, Rufus, Soranus, and Dioscurides
- selections from the
Greek Magical Papyri
- selected
passages from Greek & Latin literature (e.g. the Athenian plague as
reported by Thucydides)
- Shrines of Asclepius
- selections from the
New Testament
Objectives: This
course will examine, from a multi-disciplinary perspective, various
approaches to healing--the medical, the miraculous, and the
magical--from the Greco-Roman world and from the modern world to see
the role they played
in individuals and communities lives and the interrelationships between
these various approaches to healing. This course will also expect the
students to understand and
apply, in a critical fashion, pertinent scholarship from various
scholarly fields to the ancient (and modern) material. With over 62% of
the American population having used complementary and alternative medicine (based on a National
Center for Health Statistics survey in 2002) and with the increased
popularity of various "non-medical" approaches to healing among various
religions (e.g. 43% of Americans using complementary and alternative
approaches listed prayer as one approach they used--same 2002 survey),
the students will "form
intelligent judgements about and rational responses to" a "complex
issue," namely, healing, "they will confront as citizens in the 21st
century" (New Foundations Document, p. 21)
Relationship to the General Education
Curriculum:
CLA 300A/REL 300B, Medicine, Miracle, & Magic, satisfies the
Tier
III
requirement. The course does so in the following ways:
- When appropriate and
feasible,
professors from other disciplines (e.g. Religion, Anthropology,
Psychology, Biology) will
be asked to participate.
- Selected readings
from
various
disciplines will be required for all (e.g. Religion, Anthropology,
Psychology, Biology)
- Additional selected
readings from
various disciplines will be required for the individual student
projects
& presentations
- Class discussion
based
on the
selected interdisciplinary readings and student presentations will
facilitate
student understanding and comprehension of these various disciplines
and
the value they bring to the plays themselves and their role within
society—both the Greco-Roman and 21st century.
- Prerequisite: one of the following: LAT 101, LAT
102, LAT 203, GRE 101, GRE 102, CLA 215, CLA 227, CLA 228, REL
101, REL 102, PHI 101, PHI 102, PHI 221, SCA 111, SCA 115, PSY 112, PSY
113
Format: The
course
will consist of discussion, student presentations and some lectures.
The
class may occasionally be divided into small groups to treat discussion
topics that will most often be based on readings from ancient
authors.
Grading:
- Research Paper:
one paper
worth 200 points, 3600-6000 due
during the 12th week of the semester (or, with the approval of the
instructor two papers, worth 100 points each and each 1800-3600 words
in length, may be substituted for the one paper; in which case, the
first paper will be due during the 7th week of the semester, the second
during the 12th week)
- Final Paper: 50 points;
1200-1800
words in length
- Critical Reviews:
2 total;
each worth 25 points; each 600-900 words in length (typically one per
unit)
- Presentation: worth 50 points; based
on the research paper (or papers if 2 are done) to be presented towards
the end of the semester
- Class
Participation:
50
points; will also include posts in class discussion folder
Honor Code: All
students and faculty must adhere to the Honor Code; please see the
Student
Life Handbook for the full description of the Honor Code--p. 21
in
the Student Life Handbook gives a short definition: "No Westminster
student
shall commit any act of academic dishonesty in order to advance her or
his own academic performance, or to impede or advance the academic
progress
of others," but the sections on plagiarism and cheating are especially
important (see Honor Commission Constitution, Article IX).
ADA Accommodation: Any
student who feels that he or she may need an accommodation based on the
impact of a disability should contact me to arrange an appointment as
soon
as possible. At that time, we can discuss the course format,
anticipate
your needs, and explore possible accommodations.
Writing-Intensive
Option:
Different
types of writing will be part of the course: critical summaries,
research
papers, and a final. All papers/critical summaries will be assigned as
a means to help participants come to a better understanding,
evaluation,
and integration of important themes, ideas, and concepts. Both
critical
summaries and the research paper (or one of the papers if doing two)
will be revised on the basis of a conference with me. One of the
critical summaries and the
research paper (or one of the papers, if two chosen) must be revised on
the basis of conferences with a
tutor
at the Writing Lab. A critique and conference
after the completion of a writing assignment may also occur. In
general,
participants in the class should highly consider using the services of
the Writing Lab and especially the Lab tutors, who can be of tremendous
assistance.
Papers:
- Content: The
critical reviews should be a "critical" review, i.e. it should review
the key points and present some of the key evidence of the
material as well as provide a critique of the material. The research
paper(s) should make appropriate use of primary and secondary evidence
to address the topic chosen.
- Formatting:
- Header:
start
with a simple
heading at the top of the page giving your name, course number, a word
count, etc.
- Title of a critical summary: should be the
full bibliographic entry for the material covered
- Citations:
for
citations
follow a standard format such as the APA but note that
I prefer italicizing titles, etc. to underlining. There will be a post
in the discussion folder with examples for your aid.
- Spacing &
Font: you
may use any font, point size, or line spacing that you want--within
reason,
that is--though in an effort to save paper, single spaced is preferred.
- Submission: A
paper copy
is due at the beginning of the class period. An electronic copy of each
paper is also required and should be submitted within 24 hours of the
due
date for the paper copy; note that there is a two letter grade
deduction
for failure to submit an electronic copy.
Attendance:
Regular attendance and participation are essential for the success of
the
whole class. More than two unexcused absences will be considered
excessive, and no make-up work will be accepted for unexcused absences.
Each unexcused absence past two will result in a deduction of 7.5
points
from the total number of points one has at the end of the semester. If
you are ill, e-mail me before class, if possible, or as soon as you are
able.
Assignments:
In
each unit, the assignments and the specific due dates are not
"set-in-stone,"
and may vary depending on how each class period goes. The syllabus will
be updated as needed.
Unit I: Greco-Roman approaches &
accounts
- Reading assignments (click here--Id
& password needed)
- Philostratus' Life of Apollonius of Tyana
- Greco-Roman Medical
works: Hippocratic Corpus, Galen, etc.
- Greco-Roman
Religious works: pagan: Shrines of Asclepius (cure tablets, etc), Isis,
etc; Christian: New Testament
- Greco-Roman Magical
works: selections from the Greek Magical Papyri
- selected reading
related to guest lectures
Unit II: 20th and 21st century approaches
- Reading assignments (click here--Id
& password needed)
- Meridith B.
McGuire, Ritual Healing
in Suburban America
- selected reading
related to guest lectures
Unit III: Presentations of Student
Research
- Reading assignments (click here--Id
& password needed):